Waterproof or Breathable? Why Masonry Paint Needs to Be Both

Ask a decorator what to put on an exterior wall and you will usually get one of two answers. Some say you need something waterproof, because British rain is relentless. Others say you need something breathable, because paint that traps damp ends up flaking off. Both are right, and the best masonry paints are designed to do both jobs at once.

Here is what those two words mean, how to check a paint before you buy it, and which kind of finish suits which kind of wall.

Rain and water vapour are two different problems

A wall deals with water in two forms.

The first is liquid water: driving rain, splashback and run-off from sills and gutters. If that soaks into brick, stone or render, the wall stays wet, frost can damage the face, and damp patches can show up indoors.

The second is water vapour. Cooking, bathing and breathing all put moisture into the air inside a home, and some of it moves out through the walls. Masonry that has been soaked by rain also needs to dry out through its outer face.

If a coating stops that vapour escaping, moisture collects behind the paint. That is why some painted walls blister, bubble and peel within a few winters.

The Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings puts it plainly in its guidance on breathability: "A breathable material, by definition, cannot be impermeable and should not trap moisture."

So the job for a masonry paint is to stop liquid water getting in while letting water vapour out.

What "breathable" means on a data sheet

"Breathable" on a tin is a description, not a test result. To compare paints properly, look at the technical data sheet.

The most precise measure is the Sd value. It expresses how much a paint film resists water vapour, as the thickness of still air that would resist it by the same amount. The lower the Sd value, the more easily vapour passes through.

It is measured to BS EN ISO 7783. Under the European classification for exterior masonry coatings, EN 1062-1, a paint with an Sd value below 0.14 m falls into class V1, the highest vapour permeability band.

Not every manufacturer publishes an Sd value. Where it is missing, look for wording such as "microporous" or "vapour permeable", check what the binder is, and ring the manufacturer's technical line. A good supplier will tell you how its paint behaves on your type of wall.

How different paints get the balance

Most masonry paints sold in the UK fall into four broad families.

Which walls need which

Listed buildings and old solid walls built with lime. If your house was built with lime mortar or lime render, especially if it is listed, take advice before painting anything. Conservation officers may specify limewash or a mineral paint. Some modern products, including flexible acrylics, are rated for lime render, usually with a stabilising primer first. On a protected building, the conservation officer has the final say.

Exposed brick, block, stone and cement render. Most homes with walls that take a beating from wind and rain need a coating that holds back driving rain without sealing the wall in. This is the job for a waterproof breathable masonry paint. It sheds weather like a waterproof coating, but its microporous film still lets the masonry dry out.

What to look for: a worked example

Weatherflex, made by Kingfisher Building Products, an independent manufacturer based in Ulverston, Cumbria, is a useful example of what to look for. It was first used on barn conversions across Cumbria, where exterior walls rarely get a dry week.

Its technical data sheet describes a water-based acrylic that forms "a moisture resistant shield" while keeping "sufficient vapour permeability to allow moisture to evaporate from the substrate". It lists brick, stone, render, pebbledash and lime render as suitable surfaces, with a stabilising solution on soft or dusty substrates. It bridges cracks of 1 mm or less on the first coat, covers 8 to 10 m² per litre per coat on smooth surfaces, and is formulated to protect for up to 15 years. It comes in 72 colours.

Whichever brand you consider, look for those same details: the binder, a clear statement on vapour permeability (ideally an Sd value), crack-bridging, a realistic coverage rate and a stated service life.

Preparation decides how long any paint lasts

Even the right paint fails on a badly prepared wall. Before you open the tin:

  1. Clean the wall with water and a stiff brush, and let it dry.
  2. Kill moss, algae and lichen with a biocide wash so they do not grow back under the new coat.
  3. Repair the pointing and render. Rake out crumbling joints and fill cracks. Water getting in through failed pointing will undo any coating.
  4. Stabilise soft or dusty surfaces with a stabilising primer so the paint has something sound to grip.
  5. Watch the weather. Most masonry paints need a dry spell and a minimum surface temperature, often around 7 °C, with no rain for 24 hours after the last coat. In winter, finish by early afternoon so the paint can cure before the evening dew.
  6. Apply two coats, and paint a test patch first on large jobs to check your spread rate.

The short version

A masonry paint should keep liquid rain out and let water vapour out. On most brick, stone and render, the right choice is a microporous paint that does both. On historic lime-built walls, take conservation advice first. Whatever you choose, read the data sheet before you buy.